TV Show Review: Sherlock & Daughter (HBO Max)
I discovered Sherlock & Daughter while browsing HBO Max, and I was instantly hooked. I ended up binge-watching the entire first season, and I can confidently say it’s one of the more refreshing takes on the Sherlock Holmes universe I’ve seen in recent years. As someone who has watched multiple Sherlock adaptations—from the classic Basil Rathbone films to Benedict Cumberbatch’s modern take—this one truly stands out.
Plot Summary:
The story begins with Sherlock Holmes (played by David Thewlis) living in relative seclusion in London, haunted by the aftermath of his famous cases and the losses he has endured. His world is turned upside down when Amelia, a sharp-witted, headstrong American woman (played by Blu Hunt), shows up at his doorstep claiming to be his daughter.
Amelia’s mother, now deceased, had raised her in the U.S., and Amelia arrives in England hoping to discover the truth about her father—and herself. The pair are quickly thrust into a mystery involving international politics, the British aristocracy, and the murder of a prominent figure connected to Holmes’ past.
As they investigate, the reluctant father-daughter duo must learn to work together. Amelia brings her own cultural perspective, street smarts, and emotional intelligence, while Sherlock relies on his unparalleled powers of deduction. They’re also joined by Prince Edward (played by Dougie Baldwin), an Australian royal with secrets of his own, who brings additional tension and unexpected humor to the storyline.
Themes and Social Commentary:
What stood out most to me was how the series skillfully weaves in social and political issues without being heavy-handed. The show explores themes like racism, sexism, class struggles, and cultural clashes in both subtle and direct ways. Amelia’s identity as a biracial, American-raised woman navigating British high society creates moments of friction, but also allows for nuanced conversations about privilege, womanhood, and identity.
We also see how the treatment of women in early 20th-century England differs from what Amelia is used to in America. The dynamics between the upper class, working class, and the “invisible” labor of domestic staff (especially the maids and butlers) are handled with thoughtful writing and strong performances.
The show never shies away from the reality of systemic oppression—whether it’s women fighting for suffrage or people of color asserting their humanity. Yet, it balances these moments with humor, heart, and suspense.
Performance and Direction:
David Thewlis delivers a layered, vulnerable Sherlock, portraying both his brilliance and his emotional detachment. Blu Hunt brings a fresh, modern energy to Amelia, making her both relatable and bold. The chemistry between them feels authentic, capturing the tension of two people trying to connect across generational and cultural gaps.
The supporting cast also shines, and the production quality—costuming, cinematography, and set design—adds depth and realism to the period setting.
Final Thoughts:
Sherlock & Daughter is a smart, socially conscious twist on a classic franchise. It honors the spirit of Arthur Conan Doyle’s work while updating the story for today’s audience. It’s engaging, well-acted, and not afraid to challenge the viewer while still delivering entertaining mysteries.
I genuinely hope HBO Max renews the series for a second season. It deserves more recognition, and I believe it has the potential to reach an even broader audience.
Message me on Social media (@headphonesthoughts) (@headphonesTblog) and/or email me @ contact@headphonesthoughts.com
Whatever life takes you, enjoy your life. Think positive, and be positive.
–Always look to the rising sky
Read my quote or thought of the week series
Follow me on Social Media:
Instagram @headphonesthoughts
X @headphonesTblog
