I finally got to see the latest Wuthering Heights adaptation, and I have thoughts.
Let’s get this out of the way first: if you are expecting a faithful adaptation of the novel by Emily Brontë, this is not it. This version feels loosely inspired by the classic rather than committed to the original text. Many longtime fans of Wuthering Heights will likely notice major deviations in tone, characterization, and storytelling.
That said, this gothic romance film isn’t without merit.
Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi’s Chemistry Carries the Film
Despite some noticeable miscasting in supporting roles, Margot Robbie and Jacob Elordi deliver strong performances. Their chemistry is intense, emotionally charged, and believable. Even when the script wavers, their acting anchors the film.
Their portrayal of Catherine and Heathcliff leans heavily into obsession rather than romance — and honestly, that felt accurate to the spirit (if not the structure) of Brontë’s novel.
A Toxic Love Story — Not a Fairytale
One of the film’s strongest elements is its portrayal of Catherine and Heathcliff’s deeply toxic, codependent relationship. This is not a sweeping love story. It is an exploration of obsession, ego, pride, and emotional destruction.
Catherine is portrayed as selfish and torn — craving wealth and social status while still wanting Heathcliff. She refuses to settle, yet she cannot fully commit. Heathcliff, in turn, becomes vindictive and emotionally abusive, channeling his pain into control and manipulation. His need to possess Catherine bleeds into how he treats others, especially the woman he uses to provoke jealousy.
The film makes it clear: this love consumes rather than heals.
A Music-Video Gothic Aesthetic
Stylistically, the movie embraces a dark, gothic romance aesthetic with heavy visual symbolism and extended musical montages. The atmosphere feels almost like a high-production art film blended with modern music-video energy.
The soundtrack, including contributions from Charli XCX, adds to the moody, dramatic tone. Some songs elevate the emotional intensity. Others feel excessive and slightly distracting. At times, the montages strengthen the story. At other times, they feel indulgent.
If you enjoy stylized adaptations with bold artistic direction, this approach may work for you.
A New Perspective on Nelly
Another interesting shift is the perspective given to Nelly. Instead of being portrayed purely as a moral observer, this adaptation hints at jealousy and self-preservation in her motivations. The moral lines feel blurred, making the story more layered and less black-and-white.
It’s a 50/50 portrayal — and that nuance was compelling.
Where the Film Falls Short
While the ambition is clear, some scenes feel unnecessarily extended, particularly the intimate sequences and repetitive montages. The emotional intensity could have remained just as strong with more restraint.
For viewers seeking a detailed, generational exploration of the novel’s themes, this adaptation may feel incomplete. It captures the obsession — but not always the depth.
Final Thoughts: Is This a Faithful Wuthering Heights Adaptation?
No. It’s not a faithful literary adaptation.
But if you approach it as a gothic dark tragedy inspired by Wuthering Heights, rather than a strict retelling, it becomes more watchable. Think elevated fanfiction with high production value and strong lead performances.
I would still love to see a future adaptation that stays closer to Wuthering Heights in structure and emotional complexity. The original novel remains unmatched in its layered storytelling and generational impact.
Overall Rating: 3 out of 5
Watch it for the atmosphere and performances — not for accuracy.
Message me on Social media (@headphonesthoughts) (@headphonesTblog) and/or email me @ contact@headphonesthoughts.com
Whatever life takes you, enjoy your life. Think positive, and be positive.
–Always look to the rising sky
Read my quote or thought of the week series
Follow me on Social Media:
Instagram @headphonesthoughts
X @headphonesTblog
